The slogan “Drill, baby, drill” may be politically popular, but in the U.S. oil patch today, it’s not that simple. Despite strong political support for domestic production, rig counts are falling, not rising. And even though the U.S. is the world’s top oil producer, investment in new drilling is cooling fast. The reason? It’s not politics—it’s profitability, price pressure, and shareholder discipline.

America Leads in Oil Production, But Not in Drilling Activity
The U.S. continues to lead the world in oil production, with output hovering around 13.2 million barrels per day (bpd) as of early 2025, outpacing 2nd & 3rd:

• Saudi Arabia: ~9.8 million bpd

• Russia: ~9.3 million bpd
(Source)

Thanks to advances in horizontal drilling, hydraulic fracturing, and real-time data monitoring, the shale revolution transformed the U.S. into an energy superpower. But those gains haven’t translated into sustained profitability. After years of boom-bust cycles, oil and gas producers have shifted away from the "drill at all costs" model toward financial discipline and capital efficiency.

Rig Counts Are Dropping—Even with White House Support
You might expect drilling activity to rise under a pro-energy administration. But the numbers tell a different story.

According to Baker Hughes, the number of active drilling rigs in the U.S. stood at 610 as of April 26, 2025, down from 748 rigs in April 2024—a decline of nearly 18% year-over-year. This marks the lowest spring rig count since 2021, despite rhetoric calling for energy dominance.

So, what’s holding drillers back? It’s not federal permits or ESG pressure—it’s the market itself. Simply put, investors want returns, not production.

Shareholder Pressure and Break-Even Math Are Driving the Slowdown
In the first quarter of 2025, the five largest U.S. producers—ExxonMobil, Chevron, ConocoPhillips, EOG Resources, and Pioneer Natural Resources—focused on returning capital to shareholders. That included billions in stock buybacks and dividend increases, even as rig counts dropped.

This reflects a broader change in industry priorities: producers are now rewarded for restraint, not growth. Drilling new wells requires confidence in long-term price support, but prices today aren't cutting it.

As of early May 2025, WTI crude oil is trading in the $58–$61 per barrel range, far below the $70+ level many shale producers need to justify new drilling. Rising tariffs on imported steel and equipment, combined with higher service costs and labor shortages, have pushed break-evens higher in many basins.

Dallas Fed Survey Confirms Producers Are Cautious
According to the Dallas Federal Reserve’s December 2024 Energy Survey, which includes responses from 146 oil and gas executives, more than 60% said they would not increase drilling unless oil prices remained at or above $70 per barrel.

This survey provides a clear snapshot: even modestly lower prices can derail drilling plans, especially when companies are under pressure to live within their cash flow.

The Profitability Problem: High Output, Thin Margins
While U.S. production remains near record highs, it’s increasingly concentrated among the most efficient operators in the best acreage. But even these leaders face financial headwinds. Public oil companies have struggled to deliver consistent profits, especially in low-price environments. That’s why they’ve slowed reinvestment, reduced capital expenditure budgets, and doubled down on shareholder returns.

Private operators and smaller independents, once responsible for a large share of growth, are also pulling back. Many lack the capital flexibility or hedge protection to weather sub-$60 oil.

Geopolitics, Tariffs, and Demand Uncertainty Cloud the Outlook
The global backdrop is far from stable. Ongoing Red Sea shipping disruptions, tariffs on steel and aluminum, and uncertainty around Chinese demand are making oil markets volatile. These factors complicate pricing forecasts, and as a result, companies are wary of long-term commitments.

Even with calls for energy security, uncertainty keeps capital sidelined.

So Where’s the Upbeat Story? Policy Can Still Help
While market forces are in the driver’s seat, the government still has a role to play in supporting responsible growth. Here’s how:

• Streamline Permitting: Faster, more predictable approvals for federal land drilling and infrastructure can reduce lead times and increase flexibility.

• Incentivize Infrastructure: Investments in pipelines, LNG terminals, and gas takeaway capacity can lower costs and unlock stranded reserves.

• Targeted Tax Credits: Temporary tax relief tied to reinvestment or domestic material sourcing could help offset higher input costs.

• Regulatory Clarity: Avoiding constant policy reversals will make the U.S. a more attractive long-term investment for capital-intensive projects.

Conclusion: Production Power Without the Push
The U.S. is still the world’s energy leader, but slogans like “Drill, baby, drill” oversimplify the complex economics facing today’s producers. Oil companies are doing more with less—and doing it cautiously. With the right mix of stable prices, investor confidence, and smart policy, the U.S. can maintain its leadership without sacrificing financial discipline or shareholder trust.

To learn more about industry insights and how People's Company supports clients in navigating today’s energy landscape, visit us here.